chalkley3's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[60 Frame Collab 2]

Boring.

Some of them were pretty damn good (Dr Mario's for example), but most of them were just bad. I can put aside the crap drawing skill, but for a collab based entirely around the concept of 60 frames per person, people really just drew a bunch of shit for sixty frames without actually creating something designed to fit the limitations.

There was no entertainment value in this, and with the lack of any kind of continuity or even some kind of unifying theme, it's not worth your time.

SteakandKidneyPie responds:

Blah blah blah, I got bored reading that and it was not worth my time either

[The Bunny Suicides]

Nostalgaic

You made me remember I own this book, I completely forgot. Not bad animation, although some of the FBF could use a little more smoothing out. The sound editing needs a lot of work, add some short fades to the sound effects, it sort of sucks when the "crowd on crowd off" effects happens. Also, that music gets veeery annoying after a while. Other than that, not bad at all.

KungFu-Gerbil responds:

Thanks for the review, i'll take on board the advice, as im still learning animation techiques i hope to improve soon. Take care dude, glad we could bring back some fond memories for you (check out his2nd book btw, return of the bunnie suicides if you haven't already)

:)

[HootHoot Used Hypnosis]

Har,

As a person who has used hypnosis before, I can tell you, this wouldn't work. Great choice of song and computer killing sprite animations.

ScrewdriverClock responds:

ahahah of course it wouldn't work, nor was my intention for it to work. All of this was done for the fun of making it.

[Animation 3 Final Project]

Smooth

That's quite good. Not much for content though... Lip-synch was good.

KlinKlinK responds:

As I mentioned in the description, don't expect much from the animation. It was supposed to be no more than 30 seconds I believe.

Thanks for the review.

[HALOMEN2]

awesome

AAAH! TOO MANY CROSSOVERS!. Nah, that was great. I was getting some lag (which is unusual, so either you have the most detailed art ever or somethings amiss), but otherwise, fantastic!

danomano65 responds:

it lagged for me too. I don't know why. shouldn't tho. must be detail. we'll go with that.

[Space Goat - Episode 3]

I Love SpaceGoat but...

Okay, praise first. Animation: 10, Ideas:10, Spacegoat Fandom:10 BUT! Please acknowledge that you didn't actually make the audio, because thats plagarism and it would be such a shame to see a great animation like this go because of that. I'm sure it wouldn't detract from the movie. But other wise fantastic!

rilstix responds:

I've credited Jay and the Doctor as the creators of the fine audio, in the little audio box to the left there. Look before writing something, ta.

[Spritey-Man!]

Audio could use some work.

It was alright, not outright hilarious, but the animation was good. The song drilled into my brain after a while, very annoying. Also, this probably should have a epilepsy warning. Not bad on the whole.

Spritanium responds:

Just so you know, the person who sang this was recovering from laryngitis, so it's basically supposed to sound hilarious.