chalkley3's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Under Judgement]

Borked

Err.. you have major problems with your actionscript. When the movie loads and it goes to menu, the whole thing is very dark, and clicking on the button does nothing. I can't give you anything untill this is fixed, sorry.

[Awesome Gaiden]

Err... Awesome.

People may bitch and whine about your style, but there's no denying you ratcheted up the quality and complexity of your animations in MGA2 and this one. Good work, I can't wait for the DVD release.

[Chuck's New Tux!]

Killer Ending

Made in a cave with a box of scraps, lol.

[Brawl Taunts]

Funny

Worth the click, but I think that the generic anime style was a bit lazy. Its not as if this is egoraptor where it acutally contributes to the humore, in this case I felt it diminished the jokes and made it looked half-assed.

[Tank Epic]

O.o

That was amazing! This pico day got quite a haul of excellent submissions.

Fitting title indeed!

[House of 1000 Cats]

Jesus christ

I have never seen such a perfect execution and direction, such incredible animation (The quality of the drawings isn't the best I've ever seen, but they give the movie a unique style and feel). 5'd 10'nd and fav'd.

Seriously, keep it up guys.

[Home Made DS]

Awesome.

That was really smooth, great concept. You also did a fantastic job of tracking the animation to the video, that must have been a pain in the ass. You know what would be awesome? Having some touch screen action. It is a DS after all. Solid 10/5

[Wither]

Wow.

That was mad. However, the preloader doesn't work, at least for me. Didn't appear at the start of the movie, flashed for a frame at the very end. You might want to check your actionscript.

[The Bunny Suicides]

Nostalgaic

You made me remember I own this book, I completely forgot. Not bad animation, although some of the FBF could use a little more smoothing out. The sound editing needs a lot of work, add some short fades to the sound effects, it sort of sucks when the "crowd on crowd off" effects happens. Also, that music gets veeery annoying after a while. Other than that, not bad at all.

KungFu-Gerbil responds:

Thanks for the review, i'll take on board the advice, as im still learning animation techiques i hope to improve soon. Take care dude, glad we could bring back some fond memories for you (check out his2nd book btw, return of the bunnie suicides if you haven't already)

:)

[Super-Cannibal]

They told me...

That if I didn't vote 5, they'd take my thumbs.